I Stop Reading A YA Book When...
- vampires are introduced
- actually, scratch that: generic Twilight vampires are introduced, making it clear the author is trying to cash in on Stephenie Meyer's success by writing a novel where some randomly violent bloodsuckers sparkle and have physically- and emotionally-weak teenage girls swoon for them for no apparent reason.
- it shows any hint of becoming a novel where a beautiful, smart, popular girl seems absolutely perfect but actually it's all a show... and I lose interest. I read this plotline way too often. It has to be phenomenal for me not to dismiss it as being terribly generic.
- anyone's problems are completely solved by falling in love with another person. I mean, are you trying to encourage teenage girls to be desperate and clingy or what?
- there is a very clear message that the author is trying to put across to teenagers. Like "PRACTICE ABSTINENCE" (I am already, damn it) or "DON'T DRINK" (ditto). You can write theme novels. But they have to be great novels in their own right, not just a vehicle for a moral.
- someone's eyes are referred to as 'orbs'. The word 'eyes' works fine. Don't make me think you're talking about a wizard in Middle Earth when you're just describing someone's face.
- any girl launches into a description of how thin, tall and good-looking her best friend is. Usually these sorts of descriptions add nothing to the story or character development. They just frustrate me. I hear enough of this in real life.
- a sexy, randomly violent bad-boy character is introduced. People like this in real life wind up in juvenile detention before they finish school. They aren't desirable, they're unstable. I don't like them in books either. Random violence = not on.
- a brooding, mysterious, emo boy is introduced. Girl instantaneously falls for this character for no apparent reason.
- there is a romance between a girl who is sixteen and a guy who is some indeterminable age over twenty-five. This is one million shades of wrong. In real life, this is illegal. And in books for teenagers, rarely are there relationships where the boy is younger. (Note: Age-inappropriate crushes are mostly okay, as long as they don't go anywhere. Because if they do: I will put down the book. Be afraid.)
- any girl bemoans her total lack of boobs. I. Just. Don't. Care. Again, I hear enough of this in real life.
- the arty speech-without-quotation-marks thing is done. It frustrates me no end. Are you deliberately trying to confuse me, or did you not learn about talking marks in Grade Three?
- there's some unnecessary drug reference. Personally, I'm okay with drugs in books for teenagers. I'm okay with most things in books for teenagers. It provides a good venue for teenagers to learn about stuff within context (which none of those anti-drug pamphlets offer) without having to experience something themselves. HOWEVER drug use in books for teenagers for the sake of edginess bothers me no end.
- everyone is rich. I don't care about wealthy characters. Maybe it's an Australian thing. We always go the underdog.
- there's a prologue offering a snippet of excitement! then 200+ pages of backstory and internal dialogue and gazing at sparkly people from afar.
- teenage characters have sex with someone they're not in a relationship with (yes, I shun you casual hooker-uppers) and it's completely unnecessary to the plot and character development. It's like the author's gone, Hey! Casual teenage sex! That'll make my novel sell for it's EDGINESS. Ooh, edgy. Yeah. And everyone can take LSD and not use contraception and there will be absolutely no consequences.
- teenage characters hate their family. I can't relate to this at all. That's just me, because my family is awesome (this is bad, though, because all of my friends like my parents more than they like me).
- I could go on for some time. This post, distilled: unnecessary drugs, sex, bad boys, age differences, vampires and sparkles make me put down a teen book.
What makes you stop reading a YA novel?
One more thing: I've been interviewed at a new book blog, Reading the Best of the Best. Head over and check it out!
Oh, and: Enter this competition!
28 notes passed:
Okay, don't get freaked out, but I love you.
Um... I stop reading for the same reasons (and if some of the minor appropriate-but-totally-ridiculous aspects don't cause me to stop reading, I still dislike the book when I finish).
This has to be one of the best blog entries I've read anywhere. I need to link this.
I stop reading a YA novel when...everything you said applies.
Like seriously, I just sat here for five minutes and tried to think of something to add. You've said it all. :)
Mm, I hate it when the main character is all, like, complaining about her boobs. wtf. :/
And sparkly vampires are sexy (like Edward). But I hate other vampire books. idk. Except for Jatta. The book Jatta has made me stop lovin' vampires and start lovin' werewolves.
Whut.
I pretty much agree with everything you said. Except that I don't mind vampires. Real vampires, the kind that burn in the sun. Not sparkly, emo immortals who drink blood and knock up girls young enough to be their great-granddaughter.
I go for all of these... except the first one since my blog is all about the supernatural and stuff. Though you kind of retracted yourself on that one so, awesome!
You're the best. I agree for the most part.
I stop reading for the pretty much the same reasons. Actually, I spend lots of time researching books before reading them to make sure they don't have any of that stuff so I don't waste my time or money with something that will disappoint me.
I stop for a lot of the same reasons, but the casual sex one usually really turns me off. I'm looking for books for 7th graders for one reason! But also because it usually doesn nothing to advance the plot.
I also don't like when the plot has telltale signs of wrapping up into a nice neat ending package. Life isn't like that.
"unnecessary sex" - sounds like a band.
So great that you feel this way and you post it for other teenagers to read. I agree with you.
lofty descriptions of ANY characters amazing, perfect, good looks. shits me to tears.
I'm totally bookmarking this post. I think it will be a good checklist as we're doing final edits on a manuscript.
And for the record if there was a band called "unnecessary sex," I would totally download a song from them in iTunes.
Awesome post, Steph. And from someone who used to be a teenager *ahem* some time ago, it's great to have your perspective on this. I don't write for teens because I often don't feel like I connect with the culture...and probably because I actually really hated being a teenager when I was one. Your list has actually given me hope that maybe there's a place for one of my books one day because I can guarantee it won't feature drugs, complaining about boobs or lack thereof, a gorgeous best friend, vampires or unnecessary sex. (In fact, in may not feature sex at all. Not every teenager has sex, right?)
I am SO WITH YOU on the dramatic prologue that leads into dreary backstory. Especially when said prologue is all introspective-I'm-about-to-die-because-of-ambigious event drivel. Maybe it's just the influence of Twilight, but that seems to be everywhere lately.
(And when did the blog's layout change?! Apologies if this happened weeks ago, I usually read in Google Reader!)
Great post - like it so much I had to quote you. And love the new blog design.
My favorite post yet! Going to commit this to memory and use as a checklist for writing.
Great list.
You're a sassy one, Steph. I agree -- gratuitous & unnecessary-to-the-plot drugs/sex/language is irritating. But very few things beyond complete and utter boredom will make me put down a book.
Although I HATE when the villain's like, ok, I'm going to pause before I kill you/your dog/your boyfriend/your grandma/your social life and explain to you EXACTLY WHY AND HOW I plotted to destroy you and how you had NO IDEA it was me. [Cue evil cackle.]
Except by that time, I'm so close to the end of the book that I just finish it anyway.
Le sigh.
Aww haha I love this! You're so funny and clever. :)
I hate to see teenagers acting ridiculously slutty, and the main character being forced into questionable positions because her "best friend" is a tart of epic proportions.
I love your list. Now get out of my head.
I can't stand books where the characters do nothing but pine. Pines belong in forests. Keep it off the pages. I just finished the book where it was 3/4 pining. Hand me a lighter, please. Alright. I get it. You love the chick. Either switch POVs to third person to get the hell out of the character's head or get a damn hobby.
i pretty much agree with everything on this list, great post!
2 words: HOO-RAH!
Thank you!!!
I broke my "I'm on vacation and not supposed to be blogging" rule to come here and comment.
I love this post! I don't know who gave you slack for it, but this is a great list! I agree with everything on it! Very well done!
(and can I say, you seem like such a well-rounded and stable person, the type Anne Shirley would refer to as a kindred soul) :)
In high school, when my friends were wearing double-D's, I wore KinderKids. Argh. You can grow into womanhood, but you never get over the time when someone in the PE locker room made fun of your pathetic training bra with the words, "Ashes to ashes and dust to dust, what's a bra without a bust?"
I put down a book when the female protagonist is hooter chick from hell. I just can't relate.
If she's bemoaning her lack of boobs, I'm there. Looking back, booblessness pretty much frames my high school ego (or lack thereof), so that heroine is one I can relate to. I guess every reader is different, eh?
May I ask, what is an emo boy? I thought emos were in the ostrich family? Enlighten me please.
Love this, and Donna G's comment is right on--I hate the whole "I'm the bad guy and i CLEARLY can't actually kill you, even though I so have the upperhand right now, so I'll talk myself to literal death" bit. Drives me nutty.
I don't mind normal teenage insecurities, whether it be one's weight, height, skin color, or boob size. I also don't mind reading about an MC who thinks her best friend is uber-beautiful ... just so long as I don't have to constantly hear about it. Just show me in the way the MC acts when she's with her bestie.
I don't so much mind a bad boy. The thing I mind is the very average girl that the hot bad boy falls for ... for no reason. Or vice versa--just b/c he's bad and hot isn't a reason to fall for him, even if you are the whiny, average new girl. Characters need depth. If you leave them in the kiddie pool, you don't give them the chance to learn and grow.
I LOLed several times reading this. I also kept mentally checking my latest book to see if I did any of these things. I think I'm OK.
Just letting you know, this post earned you the title Most Likely to Succeed on the First Novels Club blog!
Great post - especially the one about everyone being rich - just inspired my own list on my blog http://wheniwasjoe.blogspot.com/2009/11/vampires-zombies-and-coincidences.html
Hope you don't mind that I linked to you.
Post a Comment